Depths of Dilemma: The Benthic Mandate
Cover image of the case

Depths of Dilemma: The Benthic Mandate

An executive procurement simulation where learners navigate a 48-hour ministerial ultimatum to endorse deep-sea mining or lose sovereign fishing quotas. Focuses on natural capital dependencies, market transition risk, and mitigation hierarchy trade-offs.

University of Bristol

In this single-episode Decision Lab, participants assume the role of Head of Global Sourcing at Thalassa Marine Foods, an international commercial seafood enterprise managing a $420M procurement budget across Pacific Island Exclusive Economic Zones (Kiribati, Samoa, and French Polynesia). The enterprise faces an immediate crisis: the Pacific Fisheries Council has issued a 48-hour ultimatum demanding that commercial fleets sign the Pacific Blue Development Compact—endorsing dual-use seabed mineral extraction in exchange for guaranteed 10-year EEZ quotas at a 25% license discount ($14M annual savings).

Simultaneously, Thalassa's primary European and North American retail supermarket buyers, representing 55% ($180M) of enterprise revenue, have issued binding notices threatening immediate contract cancellation if the company procures fish from active seabed mining EEZs. Participants must evaluate scientific oceanographic data, fleet logistics cost models, and host-nation fiscal deficits before engaging in a live AI defense with Chief Operating Officer Henrik Thorne and submitting a formal board recommendation.

The simulation guides learners through the Nature-Related Risk & Dependency Framework (TNFD/TCFD adaptation), requiring them to distinguish superficial corporate social responsibility (CSR) optics from balance-sheet operational dependencies. Participants evaluate four strategic pathways: (A) Full Quota Lock-in, (B) Royalty-Funded Offsets, (C) High-Seas Fleet Relocation, and (D) a Science-Based Benthic Exclusion Alliance funded by natural capital price premiums.

In debrief, facilitators can leverage the case to explore how physical ecosystem services directly underpin commercial asset productivity, why the Mitigation Hierarchy prioritizes Avoidance over unproven offset funds, and how executives can structure shared-value financing mechanisms to align host-nation fiscal realities with downstream buyer sustainability covenants.

Learning objectives

  • Highlight how physical nature dependencies (e.g., benthic nutrient upwelling supporting 42% of juvenile biomass) directly dictate balance-sheet asset solvency and supply-chain continuity.
  • Contrast market transition risks ($180M buyer contract delisting) with regulatory licensing incentives ($14M fee discount) to demonstrate the asymmetry of downstream commercial exposure.
  • Examine the structural limits of the Mitigation Hierarchy, demonstrating why deep-sea abyssal destruction (0% historical recovery rate) cannot be resolved through financial offset funds.
  • Illustrate how natural capital accounting and value-share pricing (14% buyer premium funding an $18.5M sovereign dividend) can bridge host-nation public revenue deficits (35% gap) without ecological destruction.

About the authors

LiveCase Studio creates high-impact immersive simulations that challenge executives to navigate complex trade-offs across strategy, sustainability, operations, and leadership.

LiveCase Studio

Interactive simulation studio designing executive decision-making experiences focused on sustainability, strategy, and organizational leadership.

Who is this for?

Mid-to-senior procurement executives, supply chain directors, sustainability leaders, and corporate strategists navigating ESG compliance, commodity sourcing, and natural resource governance.

Pricing

$2.5 / seatDegree Granting Course
$5/ seatNon-Degree Granting Course

Duration: ~7mins

Works on: Desktop, mobile, tablets

Requires: Web browser

Categories: Strategy,Sustainability

Share

FAQ

What is a LiveCase?

LiveCase is an educational and training simulation tool that immerses participants into a situation.
Please feel free to reach out to us for a demo.

How can I get a demo?

Simply contact us and we'll be happy to give you a demo.

Are there Teaching notes?

Yes! For all cases authored by LiveCase we can provide extensive Teaching Notes.
We can't make them public to avoid participants getting a hold of them, but you can simply reach out to us.

Do the participants pay or does the instructor?

You get to choose in the next step. If you "Host" (Instruct) the case, you can pick during the setup if you want to pay for the participants or they pay by themselves.

When do I/we need to pay?

We offer several options for payment depending on the situations

If you are Hosting

  • If the participants pay for the case, they will be requested to pay before joining the case.
  • If the host pays, we ask you to purchase your expected number of seats. If you need more, you can purchase more later. If you bought too many, please contact us to arrange a reimbursement.
  • Get pre-approved: You can get pre-approved for Invoice billing at a later date. If interested, please reach out to us.
How long do I have after I pay?

The purchase of the seat has no time limit except if the case is removed (hasn't happened yet), or if the methodology has changed too much.
In the extremely unlikely scenario, you can simply contact us for a reimbursement.

My payment isn't going through?

If there is a problem with the payment, please contact us and we will be happy to help.

Contact us